Color Types vs. the Big Five: What Scientific Personality Research Actually Measures

If you have taken a color quiz and then wondered what "real" psychologists use, this article explains what the Big Five is, how it differs from color types like the ones on this site, and why both can be useful as long as you know which job each one does.

Types vs. traits: the core difference

Color systems are type systems. They sort you into a category: Gold or Orange, Red or White, Crimson or Sage. Types are memorable and easy to talk about.

The Big Five is a trait system. It measures how much of five tendencies you have, each on a continuous scale. You are not "an extravert"; you score, say, at the 70th percentile for extraversion.

The difference matters because traits, like height, run along a continuum. A type system draws a line through the middle and puts people just either side of it into different boxes, even though they are nearly identical. A trait system keeps that information.

What the Big Five measures

The Five-Factor Model emerged from decades of research, much of it based on the idea that important personality differences become words in everyday language. When researchers analyzed how people rate themselves and others on descriptive words, five broad dimensions kept appearing [1]:

An introduction by Robert McCrae and Oliver John describes the model and its applications across research and practice [1].

How well does the Big Five predict things?

Trait scores also relate to real-world outcomes. For example, one large study found that each partner's own traits mattered far more for relationship satisfaction than how similar the partners were [2]. These are averages across many people, so they cannot tell you what any one person will do.

How color types map onto Big Five traits

Color systems are not built from the Big Five, but they are clearly tracking some of the same territory. Here is how the three axes of this site's quiz roughly relate:

Notice what is missing: neuroticism, or emotional sensitivity. Emotional stability is one of the Big Five dimensions of personality. Dropping it keeps a quiz upbeat, since no one gets a "worrier" color, but it leaves a real gap.

The ancient four temperaments, interestingly, did include it.

Why use a color quiz at all?

If the Big Five is better science, why bother with colors? Because they do different jobs.

Colors are for conversation. A four- or eight-color vocabulary is easy to remember in a meeting, a classroom or a relationship. It is friendly and non-threatening. It invites people to talk about how they work, without anyone feeling scored.

Traits are for measurement. If you want to understand yourself precisely, compare yourself with population norms, or do research, use a validated trait measure.

The mistake is using one for the other's job: treating a color quiz as a scientific measurement, or turning Big Five scores into rigid labels.

How the quiz borrows from trait research

The site's eight-color quiz borrows some good habits from trait research:

Two tools, two jobs

Color types and Big Five traits are cousins. Both describe real differences in how people engage with the world. The Big Five measures those differences more precisely and color types package them into memorable, friendly labels. Use colors to start conversations, and use traits when precision matters.

Want to see your three axis scores? Take the quiz, then read about the theory behind color systems.

A worked example: two people, one color

Imagine two coworkers who both get Cobalt on the quiz. On paper they are the same type: Fast, Task, Structure. Now look at their axis positions. The first lands at 92 on pace, 10 on focus and 88 on approach: a very clear Cobalt who decides instantly, leads with the problem and loves a plan. The second lands at 54 on pace, 46 on focus and 58 on approach: barely on the Cobalt side of every line, and only a few answers away from Coral, Emerald or Violet.

A type label treats these two people as identical. A trait view shows they are very different: the first is an extreme on all three dimensions, the second is a balanced generalist. In a team, the first will probably push hard for quick decisions; the second may act as a translator between styles. This is exactly the information that four-box systems throw away, and it is why the result page shows your positions instead of just the color.

Questions to ask yourself after any personality quiz

  1. Was I near the middle on anything? If so, both labels on either side probably describe you in different situations.
  2. Would people who know me well agree?
  3. Does this describe my preferences or my skills? A Steady person who has learned to decide quickly at work still prefers to reflect.
  4. What is missing? Ask whether a system says anything about emotional sensitivity, values or interests.
  5. What will I do with it? The best use of a result is a small, concrete change, such as asking a colleague how they prefer to receive feedback.

Where to go next

If you want to explore traits, look for a free, research-based Big Five inventory from a university or a public-domain item pool, and read the documentation that comes with it. If you want a fun, conversational starting point, the quiz takes three minutes.

  1. [1] R. R. McCrae & O. P. John, "An Introduction to the Five-Factor Model and Its Applications," Journal of Personality 60(2), 175-215, 1992. doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6494.1992.tb00970.x; PubMed 1635039; University of Nebraska open copy
  2. [2] P. S. Dyrenforth, D. A. Kashy, M. B. Donnellan & R. E. Lucas, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 99(4), 2010. doi.org/10.1037/a0020385; PubMed abstract

Find your personality color

Free, 18 questions, about three minutes.

Take the quiz

Related reading