The Four Temperaments Explained: From Greek Medicine to Modern Personality Talk

If you have ever called someone "sanguine" about a risky plan or "phlegmatic" in a crisis, you have used a 2,400-year-old personality system without knowing it. The four temperaments are the grandparents of almost every color quiz, including the one on this site. They are also a good case study in how an idea can be scientifically wrong and still culturally useful. Here is where they came from, what they meant, and how to think about them now.
Four fluids, four seasons
The story starts with Greek medicine, not with psychology. The Hippocratic treatise On the Nature of Man says, "The body of man has in itself blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile." W. H. S. Jones, introducing his Loeb translation, notes that Aristotle ascribed the treatise's description of the veins to "Polybus, the son-in-law of Hippocrates," and that a part of the first section is ascribed to the same Polybus in the Anonymus Londinensis. Jones dates that first section to "not earlier than 440 B.C. and not later than (say) 400 B.C." [1]. The author says a man "enjoys the most perfect health when these elements are duly proportioned to one another" and are "perfectly mingled," and that pain is felt "when one of these elements is in defect or excess, or is isolated in the body without being compounded with all the others" [1].
The treatise also ties the humours to the seasons. "Phlegm increases in a man in winter." In spring "the blood increases." In summer "bile rises in the body and extends until autumn." And "It is black bile which in autumn is greatest and strongest" [1].
Notice what is missing: personality. The early Hippocratic writers were interested in illness. The jump from fluids to character came later.
Galen turns humours into temperaments
Galen of Pergamon, a Greek physician who worked in Rome in the second century CE, is the figure who made the system enduring. Born in 129 CE, he wrote an enormous body of work on anatomy, physiology and therapeutics that dominated European and Islamic medicine for well over a thousand years [2].
By the Middle Ages the familiar four had settled in [3]:
| Temperament | Dominant humour |
|---|---|
| Sanguine (from Latin sanguis, blood) | Blood |
| Choleric (from Greek cholē, bile) | Yellow bile |
| Melancholic (Greek for "black bile") | Black bile |
| Phlegmatic | Phlegm |
The ideal person, Encyclopaedia Britannica notes, was thought to have an ideally proportioned mixture of all four; a predominance of one produced a sanguine, phlegmatic, choleric or melancholic person [3].
Why the temperaments survived
The humoral theory of disease collapsed with modern physiology. Nobody now thinks depression is caused by black bile. So why are the words still in use?
They are easy to remember. Four types, each with a vivid name, are far easier to talk about than a set of continuous scales.
They moved into art and literature. Johann Caspar Lavater's Essays on Physiognomy, published in English in the 1790s, still illustrated the four temperaments as faces [4]. Goethe and Schiller even made a Temperamentenrose, a "rose of temperaments" [5].
Temperaments in modern psychology
In the twentieth century, psychologists returned to the old idea with new tools. The Big Five trait model includes extraversion and neuroticism among its five factors [6].
What the ancient scheme got wrong was the cause (fluids), the tidiness (four boxes), and the idea that the boxes were fixed.
Separately, a popular branch of type psychology revived the four temperaments by name. David Keirsey and Marilyn Bates's Please Understand Me (1978) presented four temperaments derived from Myers-Briggs type theory [7], and in the same year Don Lowry built True Colors on Keirsey's work, renaming the temperaments Gold, Blue, Green and Orange [8].
What to take from the temperaments today
Use them as vocabulary, not verdicts. "I'm feeling a bit phlegmatic about this" is a charming way to say you are not worried. "He's a melancholic, he'll never lead" is a misuse.
Remember most people are mixtures. Even Galen considered the well-balanced mixture the ideal. In modern trait terms, scores near the middle of a dimension are exactly where four-box systems are least accurate.
Notice that context matters. The same person can be choleric at work and phlegmatic at home. Situations shape behavior, which is why the quiz reports where you landed on each axis rather than only a single label.
Enjoy the history. Few ideas have lasted as long. When you take a color quiz, you are participating in a conversation about human differences that began in ancient Greece, passed through Galen's Rome, medieval monasteries, Goethe's Weimar and 1970s workshops, and is still going.
Curious where you land? Take the free quiz or read the full history of personality colors.
A quick, playful self-check
Just for fun, ask yourself two questions the old temperament theory implied. First: when something exciting happens, do you tend to respond quickly and outwardly, or slowly and inwardly? Second: when something goes wrong, does your mood tend to bounce back fast, or linger? Quick and bouncy suggests sanguine; quick and lingering, choleric; slow and lingering, melancholic; slow and bouncy, phlegmatic. Most people will recognize themselves in more than one, which is the most modern lesson of all.
- [1] W. H. S. Jones, trans., "Nature of Man," in Hippocrates, vol. IV, Loeb Classical Library, 1931 (Internet Archive scan). archive.org/details/hippocrates04hippuoft
- [2] Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Galen." britannica.com/biography/Galen
- [3] Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Humour (ancient physiology)." britannica.com/science/humor-ancient-physiology
- [4] Wellcome Collection via Wikimedia Commons, "Temperaments, from Lavater, Essays on physiognomy, 1793." commons.wikimedia.org
- [5] Klassik Stiftung Weimar, "Die Temperamentenrose." klassik-stiftung.de
- [6] R. R. McCrae & O. P. John, "An Introduction to the Five-Factor Model and Its Applications," Journal of Personality 60(2), 1992. doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6494.1992.tb00970.x; PubMed 1635039; University of Nebraska open copy
- [7] Internet Archive, Please Understand Me by David Keirsey and Marilyn Bates, 1978. archive.org/details/pleaseunderstan00keir
- [8] True Colors Workshops, "About True Colours." truecolorsworkshop.com