From Goethe's Rose of Temperaments to Online Quizzes: How Color Became Personality

The four temperaments are ancient, but for most of their history they had no colors. Sanguine was not red and melancholic was not blue. So when, and how, did color and character get tied together? The answer runs through a physicist's prism, a poet's watercolor, a Swiss psychologist's cards and a California workshop. Here is the story.

Newton puts color in a circle (1704)

Isaac Newton's Opticks, first published in 1704, reported his experiments splitting white light with prisms and arranged the spectrum's colors around a circle [1][2]. Newton's circle was physics, not psychology, but it gave European thinkers a powerful new picture: colors as an ordered system with opposites and neighbors. Mapping colors onto people borrows that structure.

Isaac Newton's diagram of a color circle divided into segments labeled with color names
Newton's colour circle from Opticks. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Goethe and Schiller's rose of temperaments

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe and his friend, the playwright Friedrich Schiller, made the Temperamentenrose, the "rose of temperaments" [3].

Goethe went on to publish Zur Farbenlehre (Theory of Colours) in 1810. Its sixth part, "Sinnlich-sittliche Wirkung der Farbe," states that "die einzelnen Farben besondre Gemüthsstimmungen geben," that individual colors produce particular moods [4].

Goethe's watercolor color circle from 1809 with handwritten labels around a ring of colors
Goethe's colour circle "for symbolizing the human mind and soul life," 1809. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The 20th century: color as a test (1947)

The next big step came from Basel. Max Lüscher, born there in 1923, became fascinated by how people respond to colors. According to the foundation that preserves his work, he presented an early form of his color test at the first World Congress of Psychology in Lausanne in 1947 and completed his doctoral thesis at the University of Basel in 1949 on color as a psychological means of examination [5].

The Lüscher test flipped Goethe's idea around: instead of colors affecting your mood, your preferences among colors would reveal your state of mind. In its short form you rank eight colored cards [6]. Researchers have since questioned its validity [6], but it made "your color choices reveal you" a mainstream idea.

Colors as friendly labels (1978 onward)

A different branch of the story uses color not as a test stimulus but simply as a name. In 1978 David Keirsey and Marilyn Bates published Please Understand Me, which described four temperaments derived from Myers-Briggs type theory [7]. That same year, Don Lowry founded True Colors, which expands upon Keirsey's four temperament types with four colors, Blue, Gold, Green and Orange, so that both children and adults could easily apply them. True Colors is used in schools, businesses, government and nonprofit organizations [8].

Taylor Hartman's The Color Code followed in 1987 [9]. DISC, another four-type model used at work, goes back to William Moulton Marston's 1928 book Emotions of Normal People [10]. Insights Discovery, founded in 1993, built a four-color model on Carl Jung's typology [11].

What all of these share is a practical insight: colors make abstract personality ideas easy to remember and safe to talk about. "I'm a bit of a Green" is less loaded than "I'm introverted and analytical."

The internet era

Online, color quizzes multiplied. They are cheap to build, fun to share and easy to understand. A quiz built from Barnum statements will fit almost anyone (see why quizzes feel accurate). Meanwhile research has moved in a more careful direction, studying how colors and emotions are associated across cultures [12] and why people prefer certain colors [13].

Where this site's quiz fits

The site's quiz belongs to the "color as a friendly label" branch. It does not ask your favorite color or claim colors change you. It asks 18 questions about how you decide, connect and organize, and uses eight colors as names for the combinations. You can read exactly how it works in How the quiz works.

Why the story matters

Knowing the history helps you read any color quiz with the right mix of enjoyment and skepticism. The temperaments were an ancient attempt to explain differences; Goethe gave colors emotional meaning; Lüscher tried to make color preference a diagnostic tool; True Colors and the Color Code turned color into a shared language. Each step added something memorable, and none of them turned color into a scientific measure of personality. The full, sourced timeline has every date.

What each era got right, and what it got wrong

It is easy to look back at these ideas and laugh. It is more useful to ask what each one noticed correctly.

Newton noticed that colors have an order and that the spectrum can be bent into a circle.

Goethe noticed that color is an experience, not just a wavelength, and that people attach feelings and meanings to colors. Modern research on color-emotion associations across cultures echoes that intuition, even though his physics was mistaken [12].

Lüscher noticed that people have strong, sometimes surprising reactions to colors and that those reactions can be a doorway into conversation. Where he overreached was in treating color rankings as a reliable diagnostic test [6].

How to read the next color quiz you see

Once you know the history, you can ask three quick questions of any color quiz. Is it using color as a test (your color choices reveal you) or as a label (your answers to questions get a color name)? Does it say where its ideas come from? And does it admit what it cannot do? A quiz that answers those questions honestly is worth your three minutes. One that promises to reveal your soul from your favorite shade of blue is entertainment, which is fine too, as long as everyone knows it.

Why four, and why color?

Two choices recur throughout this history. The first is the number four: four humours, four temperaments, four True Colors, four Color Code colors, four DISC styles. The second is color. The quiz here keeps the color but moves to eight, using three dimensions instead of two, on the view that the extra nuance is worth one more thing to remember.

  1. [1] I. Newton, Opticks, London, 1704 (scan). archive.org/details/optickstreatise00newta
  2. [2] Wikimedia Commons, "Newton's colour circle." commons.wikimedia.org
  3. [3] Klassik Stiftung Weimar, "Die Temperamentenrose." klassik-stiftung.de
  4. [4] J. W. von Goethe, Zur Farbenlehre, vol. 1, Tübingen, 1810 (Bayerische Staatsbibliothek scan). archive.org/details/10857915bsb
  5. [5] Max Lüscher Stiftung, "Biography." luscher-color.com/en/biography
  6. [6] R. D. Picco & M. T. Dzindolet, "Examining the Lüscher Color Test," Perceptual and Motor Skills 79(3), 1994. doi.org/10.2466/pms.1994.79.3f.1555; PubMed abstract
  7. [7] Internet Archive, Please Understand Me, 1978. archive.org/details/pleaseunderstan00keir
  8. [8] True Colors Workshops, "About True Colours." truecolorsworkshop.com
  9. [9] Internet Archive, The Color Code by Dr. Taylor Hartman, catalogued 1987. archive.org/details/bwb_S0-BPM-441
  10. [10] DiSC Profile, "History of DiSC." discprofile.com
  11. [11] Insights, "Insights Discovery: Validating the System" (PDF). insights.com (PDF)
  12. [12] D. Jonauskaite et al., Psychological Science 31(10), 2020. doi.org/10.1177/0956797620948810; PubMed 32900287; University of Lausanne open copy
  13. [13] S. E. Palmer & K. B. Schloss, PNAS 107(19), 2010. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0906172107; PubMed Central

Find your personality color

Free, 18 questions, about three minutes.

Take the quiz

Related reading